invisible officer

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 767 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Panzerschreck Costs #191987
    invisible officer
    Participant

    Well, since Otto Morawietz was sent from Heereswaffenamt to Sicily to get a captured Bazooka home there are discussions about Panzerschreck, Panzerfaust and Bazooka.  Often just using the names, not the exact types.

    Development was fast but not without risks, Otto told about a presentation in front of high brass, including “him”. The Panzerfaust exploded and the man’s head flew away, The Reichskanzler loosing his breakfast. Otto told that with a smile but I still liked his wife’s plum cake.

    Max Ranges increased a lot. And in 1944 additional Splitterring option.

    Historically correct types and available numbers are a game writers nightmare. In 1944 the Red Army captured big stocks, so the use was not uncommon. A Battle of Berlin Red Army squad without would be strange.

    —

    Well, soldiers and weapons. Some GI loved the MP 40, using captured ones a lot. Other stated the magazine problems.

    The high MG 42 ROF is a fact. But German MG training in LMG / bipod configuration is for aiming at target and firing a 3 round burst. Next aiming, next burst. Still teached with Bundeswehr, to make it easier the MG 3 ROF was reduced.

    I got my German LMG intro at Panzerbrigade 8 at Lüneburg in the 80’s. Three days in barracks. Life amo only. That scientist spent a lot of time with the NATO forces over 4+ decades. OK, officer style treated. (I like the British officer’s food best)

     

    In SMG / Tripod configuration it is used with Tiefenstreueinrichtung to control an area, so bursts of 15 rounds are normal. But hardly sustained fire Vickers / 08 MG style.

    The barrel heats fast.

    German army had no HMG like the ,50 or Soviet 14,7 mm. They punched through walls that stopped a MG 42 bullet. What is more effective?  So very difficult to write rules that make all happy.

     

     

     

    in reply to: Spotters and Self-propelled Artillery #191986
    invisible officer
    Participant

    Well, I ever asked for realism but it was to little avail.

    So things like hand grenades ….., missing in a platoon game??? . Long discussions about armed medics, normal at Eastern front.

    BA is a mix of game for all weapons but the ranges are a big problem. Ground scale , weapon ranges compared to vehicle size for example. Some larger vehicles should have different post codes at front and aft.

    The wish for a point system is a basic problem. In most games there are gaps in that. And we all met the math genius that made the best of the available points. Not ever using historical basings.

    One artillery rule problem is the time to go into position in WW 2. No GPS. For indirect fire you need the exact position. Using Richtkreisel and dial sight and doing the calculations. Even SPG batteries needed 30 + minutes for exact indirect fire. So it was often done over the thumb in 10 + 15 minutes. The grunts having to live with the results.

    30 Minutes compared to the infantry fast reaction. So a rule might include less effective spotting

     

    But most gamers would like the SPG to go on table and fire next turn. Realism?  How many turns in game? So the rule writers found it easier to bring SPG into a game situation for direct fire only.

    in reply to: Spotters and Self-propelled Artillery #191984
    invisible officer
    Participant

    Bolt Action is a game that is far away from real world. By intention.  Add the myriad of rule changes since first start and you might get upset. But I still like it. Being historical scientist by profession I even helped writing some campaign books. Doing historical background research.

     

    Your Hummel problem, hmmm. A main problem in the game is the ratio. We field infantry groups more or less in 1/1 but bigger stuff singly.

    Many gamers field stuff you would hardly have seen at the front line. Like heavy artillery. Esp. not as single guns, not batteries. And so we see the single Tiger in many games, not a group.

    A Hummel was part of a battery. It would not engage in small firefights at the front line. You are right, the SPG had spotters. But they worked for batteries or Abteilungen, not single SPG. Com circle was with battery CO, not single guns.

    Heavy guns had AT amo for emergencies. If enemy tanks broke through the line they used it. But did not create that situation by intent. If the last Hummel of a tank division was attacked, there are hardly any spotters left.

    OK, being from an artillery family I go for the very big guns. In my games they are often objectives. Like my big 21 cm mortar.

    in reply to: Bazooka\Panzerfaust shape charge weapons #191056
    invisible officer
    Participant

    BA is not an exact reprentation of real WW II.  Just a fun game. For Panzerfaust 150 the German forces had a Splitterring that could be fixed and

    made it into an Anti Personal weapon.

    Similar got used  on the Stielhandgranate to change that blast weapon into a splinter one.

     

    Other shaped charge eapons had an anti personal option too.

     

    The problem with a game is that the real world offer so many variants of weapons and fighting that the number of rules to represent  would be nearly endless.

    in reply to: Points balance #190943
    invisible officer
    Participant

    Even if You’re not fluent in German Rohwer / Hümmelchen  Chronik des Seekrieges  1939 – 45 is a great source.  Giving OOB for nearly all small channel actions. (And more all over the world)

    There are also internet day by day chronicles like that.

     

    in reply to: Points balance #190906
    invisible officer
    Participant

    My friends and I use historical settings  and judge the quality of the gaming by comparing original outcome with the game ones.

     

    So if in our AMC Komet breakthrough games Komet survives its a German win. If it is lost its a British, even if all RN vessels are lost.

     

     

    Attachments:
    in reply to: Japanese torpedoes stupidly OP? Discussion welcome. #190143
    invisible officer
    Participant

    Well, the long lance torpedo had a crazy long range. More than once allied forces returned to old course, thinking having  succeeded in outrunning them. Then:  Bang.

    The rules do just reflect reality.

    Playing  pacific I would expect that the USN was inferior in that aspect.   Late war radar and new tactics changed that. 41-43 I would expect a Japanese force winning.

    Most Gamers want games with equal chance forces. OK if You are not interested in a historical basing. But  some are like me, being more interested in historical abilities of vessels. So I like these rules.

    invisible officer
    Participant

    The main problem is that the gamer has a composition option at all. So the math wizards are building unhistorical monster units.

     

    In German army the LMG was the last weapon to drop. Every soldier was trained to serve it and most units collected more in battle. Not just the German ones but also British or Soviet. Esp. in the defensive fights of 44/45 the extra firepower for a unit was valued. If a weapon was overheated no barrel change but just using another.

     

    The other problem is the low effect in game. The reason is, that a game gets boring when the gamers avoid the arcs of fire. Like in real war.

    in reply to: Penetration #189636
    invisible officer
    Participant

    In real life there had been splinter rings to fix to the Panzerfaust head.  So it could be used like an HE grenade too.     The PIAT was even better for that role. With no backblast safe to use in rooms or trenches.

    in reply to: War wagons #189533
    invisible officer
    Participant

    The temple of Ramses III relief show the carts  drawn by more than two oxen (= Slow) and with just one axle in mid of base (= unstable)  They seem to be ordinary trasport, carrying the belongimgs and kids. So more like a modern camper, not an APC.

     

    Instead of adding power to a force they would seperate the fighters into the “crews” of a few peoples. With civilists in the way.   Formed into a line , following each other, they might prevent the enemy war vehicles from crossing that line.  But the far more mobile chariots will pass and pepper the targets with arrows and spears. Dwars line would be even more vulnarable.

     

    Only very good tactical managing would make the carts into a Hussite style moving castle. And for good reasons these had been 4 wheeled.

     

    The relief clearly shows the Egyptian forces clearing out the carts one by one.  I think they got attacked on the march and the men had no time to form a fighting line on foot. Trying the best to defend the families. No hint that they formed a wall.

     

    So for me: Just baggage train

    in reply to: Artillery Observers #189493
    invisible officer
    Participant

    The real observer was an expert. Specially trained and normally doing nothing else. A spotter was just an ordinary man that had a base training in gun spotting. Every officer and NCO had that ability in the big armies.   So the different rules are historically correct.

     

    But  armies tended to misuse specialists. Not just in desperate situations.   Well mostly.  My own father was in WW II an artillery observer. Following the destruction of the guns he was used as infantry.   Badly wounded and POW.

    in reply to: Woods and Streams #189135
    invisible officer
    Participant

    The problems with woods in games are old, as old as modern wood farming post WW II.  It starts with wrong ideas about woods being a light problem for movement and vision.

     

    Modern men are used to the cleaned industrial woods of today.  Hardly any undergrowth.  Like city parks.  WW II was fought in old style woods.  Some thick undergroth was normal. The edge of such a forrest was like a wall. No way to look into it. And the trees closer to each other.

    And in WW II there had been woods that had been even more xxx. Like the Reichswald in Western Germany. Allied soldiers, that knew the jungls of Far East, had been astonished about that European Jungle.  No way to move away from the paths and zero visibility.

    —

    Another wrong idea is the idea of woods giving cover. In fact HE bursts on trees have a much increased effect on human flesh.   So to do an ambush at woods edge (like that on Irish Guards in A bridge to far movie) is a stupid idea.  Worse, the edge of  a forrest is easy to range in by artillery. So German AT and infantry  units would have taken a camouflaged dug in position   in front of that wood.

     

    In Reichswald they hacked paths with vision cover on top, giving access to bunkers built to control the bigger paths.

     

    —

    I like the BA ways to give the gamer wide options.   Not reducing the gamer to slaves of mechanics.

     

    in reply to: Too hard to paint Epics #189134
    invisible officer
    Participant

    Well, You gave te answer yourself.

    “…..for years and year…”

     

    I’m sure You use the standards with small scales,  like much stronger color differences than in reality.    The merge in a mess  thing can be seen with 1/1 scale real items at a distance. A 15 mm is like a real human in a long distance.

     

    I’m lucky, even with 60 I need no optical aids.   But some of my friends got the problems decades ago.

     

    in reply to: LuftFaust – Fliegerfaust Proposals #189021
    invisible officer
    Participant

    The nine barrels of Fliegerfaust B produced a shotgun effect. At 500 m it was a 60 m circle.  So one can expect just one or two  its. And the expected 500 m range was never reached with the pre series front trial weapons.The circle  was reported as 10% of range, so 10 m at 100 m.

    Around Saarbrücken a few of the front test series got used but scored no hits. The reports never reached the Waffenamt.

     

    In may 45 some had been in Berlin, there is no report of any hits. Only proof for being there are pics taken at the door of famous Adlon Hotel, showing three fired Fliegerfäuste.

     

    A C version did not exist, there was a weapon for 3 cm but that never made it from the drawing board.

     

     

    In preparation of the Berlin rules the BA makers asked a professional military history scientist that had access to the German archives and spoke with many 45 witnesses for an exhibition about the Berlin fightsin 1995. He was able to assure thewriters that there was not a single plane damaged or shot down by that thing.

     

     

    invisible officer
    Participant

    Its the typical rules wording over real world BA tournament  fuss. One reason why I avoid these like hell.

    With the German army having no long Gewehr since 1935, but just a Karabiner / Carbine for all arms , that is just nuts. That a writer did name the K98 k by mistake a rifle is for some anal tournament rule lawyers heavenly given law. In WW 2 Wehrmacht the words got used synonimous.

     

    Having no swords in field service since Weimarer Republik the mounted German  OR had to use the K98k.  He also had no pistol. OK, spitting in the foes eye…..

     

    Mounted shooting was trained a lot.  Even some tricks like standing on horse back and shooting.  For that You need a superbly trained warhorse.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 767 total)