Robbie

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #154492
    Robbie
    Participant

    Dear Henry

    When Bill McGill makes the comment, “I don’t think there ever was a rumour, just wishful thinking” I would suggest he is not referring to the attendees of the Boot Camp getting the new rule book.
    I think he means it is wishful thinking that Warlord Games would take a financial hit and undertake a significant administrative effort by supplying new rulebooks to those sold the 1st edition with its many errors.

    #154472
    Robbie
    Participant

    I don’t suppose there is an announcement either saying this rumour is false or confirming it is happening?

    #152781
    Robbie
    Participant

    This is actually a tricky one because the two interpretations people have put forward are both of similar validity. Some would point to the fact that the re roll replaces whatever result was rolled and draw from it that this would allow further orders to be given. Others would point to the fact that a failed roll means that the Brigadiers should stop and the re roll is the General intervening. If you like The Brigadiers messenger is shot down and the General and his staff intervene to allow the required movement to take place.

    Both interpretations can argue validity because the rules do not have that vital final clarification; If the re roll is successful it only applies to that order OR if the re roll is successful, then the Brigadier can continue issuing orders.

    For clarity’s sake, I started this debate thinking no further rolls should occur. I now am moving to the opposite opinion. This is because the reroll can take place for successful as well as failed orders. This fact only makes sense if new order fully replaces the old order and that further orders can then be issued by the Brigadier.

    However it would be very useful if an answer from the rule writer or Warlord games could clarify this.

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)