• Home
  • Webstore
  • News Archive
  • Events Calendar
  • Contact Us
  • Forum
Warlord Games Statement
Back to homepage

Advanced search
  • Board index ‹ Pike & Shotte ‹ Pike & Shotte General Discussion
  • Change font size
  • Print view
  • FAQ
  • Register
  • Login

The Reapers War

Post a reply
Previous topic • Next topic • 16 posts • Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2

The Reapers War

Postby DOGGED » Fri Jul 17, 2009 9:29 am

Hello. Don't know if this is quite the right place to put it, but I just wanted to introduce you to a very unknown front of the Thirty Years War, one that nonetheless played a big part referring the clash between Spain and France. Sorry for the looong post.

The Reapers War (catalan: Guerra dels Segadors) is the “official” name for the catalan insurrection started in spring 1640 which ended with the Peace of the Pyrinees in 1659. To start, Catalunya is located in the NE part fo the iberian peninsula. Starting with the hispanic mark stablished by carolingians in the 8th century, one hundred or so years later it was swiftly gaining independence until it had got it by the 10th century. The territories were divided into different counties but they shared family ties and the count of Barcelona was recognised as head of them all, like a big brother or a primus inter pares. By 1137 the county of Barcelona (that is, Catalonia) joined with the kingdom of Aragon and both became the Crown of Aragon, a confederal state that was later to include for centuries the kingdoms and territories of Valencia, Mallorca, Sardegna, Malta, Sicily, Naples and the duchies of Athens and Neopàtria in Greece (these just for the whole 14th century) , and hold by the beginnings of the 13th century (just before incorporating Valencia and Mallorca) the whole SE part of France, that is, the Languedoc and Provence (territories lost after the albigensian crusades against the catarism).

By the late 15th century the crowns of Aragon and Castilla were united by marriage. But the result was a composite monarchy: the heirs would become kings of the Spains (in plural, the first goal may have been to separate kingdoms for different heirs but lack of them made that impossible), each of the former states still being sovereign and having its own laws and constitutions, forming a practical confederation with common goals but different administration. But the constant warring and expansionism of the spanish branch of the Habsburgs would work easier with a centralised state; the confederation needed working kings, with a knowledge and interest in politics and administration and with a will to work for the kingdoms, at least as mush as to rule the kingdoms. The first spanish Austrias (their Habsburg branch) were more capable and took time to call for courts and try to rule both Castile and Aragon but the late kings didn’t bother and preferred to let the government in hands of ambitious noblemen with no real capability to rule, but just to look for own aggrandisement or to embark Castile in costly and absurd imperialist wars (that’s why the Quixote is so accurate in reflecting the nobility inability to involve in practical ruling and tendency to get into costly and impractical enterprises). The reluctance shown by the crown of Aragon about intervening in these “exercises” strained its relation with the monarchs, who couldn’t care less about their subjects’ feelings or welfare (go tell the dutch). When that reluctance extended to money, the relationship was inexistent, and Olivares, favorite of the ruling king, thought about a centralisation project that was to reduce the former members of the crown of Aragon to the same state of servitude that Castile endured. To ease it and effectively occupy tha catalan countryside, he transferred there the tercios with the excuse of a possible french invasion (catalans had a long tradition about fighting only defensive, season wars with temporary local armies in own territories). And the ultimate result was revolt and war. It was caused by (briefly):

-Constant abuses, raping and robbering by the spanish tercios stationed in Catalonia (catalan: Catalunya), for many years before the insurrection. The tercios were allocated in farmers’ homes and cities, living in private houses, and were obligated by catalan law to buy their maintenance. This observation of the law was in practice null and void because of the soldiers making their own will, forcing their hosts to provide them with everything they so wanted, robbing them, raping their wives and daughters, bullying them, beating and even killing those who dared to denounce them, sacking churches and public buildings... It may seem too much but it’s well supported by extensive documentation. In response, each year saw an increasing number of commotions, even revolts, engulfing the catalan countryside to the point that spanish troops couldn’t move if they weren’t in enough numbers for fear of the peasants ambushing them. The tercios were stationed in Catalunya officially for the chance of a french invasion but really to act as an occupation army, because of...

-Count Duke of Olivares (catalan: Comteduc d’Olivares) trying for years to overcome catalan constitutions, a series of rights and exemptions gained by contract with the monarchy- not just given by the kings by mercy or own will but negotiated with the catalan institutions. This was because these rights granted Catalunya, for example, didn’t have to raise offensive but just defensive armies and for a determined time (usually just for one campaign so people could get back to work in time). Catalunya didn’t have to give subsidies to the monarchy unless the king called for the Courts (parliamentary ones), and then only if legislative reforms had been resolved before by accord between the royal negotiators and the parliamentary ones. The spanish king called for Courts twice before the insurrection, and twice he left because of the catalans’ negative to augmentation of taxes and Olivares centralist project and their willing for the king fixing abuses by the tercios and the creation of a special court of justice. This unconclusive use of the parliamentary courts brought legislative stagnation and the obvious thought that the spanish king, or better said, the spanish valido (all powerful prime minister in practice) just wanted money, not caring for their subjects’ welfare. Olivares project, the Unión de Armas, overrated Catalunya in demographic and economic terms, demanding the creation of a too big catalan army and the paying of too much money. The royal will to opress catalan freedoms and (over) taxing them provoked at last a rural revolt that sparked an institutional, political and urban one.

-It has to be counted upon that Catalunya was not just another province of the so called spanish empire. It had been a separate realm and still had its own codes, the named constitutions. Catalunya had not been conquered, but had become a part of the Spains (in plural), with Aragon, Valencia and the Illes Balears (the Balearic Islands) in par with Castilla, and keeping its own institutions, legislations and rights. Being the spanish a composite monarchy, this was to be observed always as it was a primary conditoin of the right of the spanish king to rule over Catalunya (and other such territories). The reason other members of the Crown of Aragon not revolting was mainly due to the fact that the tercios weren’t stationed there and that the Unión de Armas was not so harshly obliged to them.

In 1640, the increasing commotions of before had become a full revolt. The tercios were at first cornered by the catalans and had to retreat into fortresses or beyond the catalan borders. The subsequent spanish invasion of Catalunya got under way and the invading tercios won several battles, beating the hurriedly formed catalan army while the catalans looked for french aid (it has to be reminded that Catalunya had not the demographic capability to compete with Castilla, nor the economic power to pay for mercenaries). That help came into being with Louis XIII becoming Count of Barcelona and sovereign of Catalunya. The tercios were stopped and soundly beaten back at their assault of the fortress at Montjuïc, and then were pursued until they got to their point of departure.

The war fully raged on for the next years, with alternatives. Catalan guerrilla forces constantly fell upon spanish forces and convoys and the french-catalan armies fought their spanish enemies in a good number of battles and sieges, until the Fronde wars got french attention anywhere else. The french troops, firstly received as protectors and liberators, in time behaved more or less like the tercios, and sparked a good deal of antifrench revolts.

When in 1652 Barcelona fell to spanish hands, the spanish king had to swear the catalan constitutions and restore catalan institutions, but reserving for himself the right to appoint candidates for them, even respecting the promotions given to catalans by their french king in the war. Catalan and french resistance followed until 1659, with offensives that kept the northern part of Catalunya under french-catalan hands. With the Treaty of the Pyrinees, the french got the whole of the transpyrenean catalan country, that is, the Rosselló (the Roussillon, although it comprised too the Conflent, Vallespir and part of Cerdanya). This territorial gain was conceded by the spanish monarchy in preference over giving territories in Flanders.

This is a significant fact explaining the low prestige of the spanish monarchy in Catalunya, and the lack of caring of the spanish kings over their catalan subjects (as a factor in that catalan revolt and ulterior ones). The Roussillon had always been catalan until then, while Flanders was only won as a burgundian inheritance less than 200 years before, and was populated by people willing for their independence while catalan subjects in Roussillon just wanted to be kept as part of Catalunya. Later french offers to swap the Roussillon for places in Flanders were to be ignored too.This even demonstrates the lack of vision of the spanish monarchy, preferring far away, well protected but hard to defend places to an older domain that could be transformed in an ideal buffer area, suppoted by the natural wall of the Pyrenees. Louis XIV, who had a better understanding, put Vauban to improve the already formidable fortresses in the Roussillon.

Lastly, again I’m sorry for the long post, but I thought this conflict deserves to be explained and known. It is really the first step of the burial of the spanish empire and it has its good share of battles, sieges and skirmishes. OK no Rocroi and so very big battles, but the jacobite wars were in this terms too. The TYW-ECW ranges perfectly adapt to the Guerra dels Segadors, specially as you only need french and (speculative) catalan standards so... Come to the french-catalan side!

And there’s plenty of tercios out there!

ALEA IACTA EST
User avatar
DOGGED
Legionary
 
Posts: 69
Joined: Fri Jul 17, 2009 7:50 am
Top

Re: The Reapers War

Postby rasmus » Thu Jun 09, 2011 11:37 am

After a trip to Barcelona, this does seem an interesting part of the TYW to take a look at - even more as it would also give the option for some small guerrilla action games
Cry Havoc, and let loose the dogs of war
rasmus
Cornicen
 
Posts: 160
Joined: Fri Oct 16, 2009 7:07 pm
Top

Re: The Reapers War

Postby DOGGED » Thu Jun 09, 2011 2:55 pm

Just a bit for starts:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catalan_Revolt
As you said, plenty of opportunities for skirmishing, plenty of siege war and a few big battles, most were little ones...
ALEA IACTA EST
User avatar
DOGGED
Legionary
 
Posts: 69
Joined: Fri Jul 17, 2009 7:50 am
Top

Re: The Reapers War

Postby mikeland » Mon Jun 13, 2011 1:05 pm

@dogged
Great post! This sounds like a very interesting conflict, that I have to admit I myself had not really registered. I'm sure some of the Warlord Clubmen could be used as gurilla fighters mixed in with the rank and file.
"I've been a frickin' evil doctor for 30 frickin' years! So cut me some frickin' slack."
User avatar
mikeland
Imperator
 
Posts: 4462
Joined: Wed Sep 22, 2010 5:15 am
Top

Re: The Reapers War

Postby Txabier » Tue Jun 14, 2011 1:47 am

The first part in the list of reasons is a bit exaggerated and inacurrate. The Tercios were not allocated to private houses (the number of mean in each one was too big for noble's house to sustain for long periods of time... let alone a typical farmer's one!), but with the Catalonian court refusing the funds demanded by the King (or more appropiatelly by Count-Duke de Olivares) salaries and rations were quite noticed by their absence. So, the men pillaged the countryside.

What grabs my attention is that the Catalonian make these claims of incredible and constant abuses, while Naples, Mallorca, Sicily, Malta and other Mediterranean cities where Tercios were also stationed had no qualms about the money and business their soldiery brought them, nor such a long list of bad deeds done unto them by the "evil and abusive Spanish Tercios".

All in all, I do agree that Olivares just wanted to prompt a war, yet not with Catalunya but with France. He foresaw that the Catalonians would indeed revolt--and there was constant rumours of secession prior to the occupation by the Imperial Tercios; Catalonian "loyalties" were always questioned by various courtly advisors--and having no real power to oppose the "invading army" they would call upon the French. Which was exactly Olivares always wanted and what happened, much to everybody's chagrin.

Now, please bear in mind that I am not calling anyone a traitor or some such. I am just pointing at the other historical facts that lead to the Reapers War. Catalunya would neither secceed nor was it a major military objective. It was a county--not realm--that was too eager to get the Spanish gold, but quite hard to accept any taxation by the Crown, so that made it a minor but relevant factor for the real war to come: that of the continental hegemony between Spain and France...

Which it must be said, was Olivares biggest screw-up, yet.
Last edited by Txabier on Tue Jun 14, 2011 4:10 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Txabier
Raw Recruit
 
Posts: 16
Joined: Mon Apr 25, 2011 1:41 pm
Top

Re: The Reapers War

Postby DOGGED » Tue Jun 14, 2011 9:02 am

While in no way trying to start a political confrontation which is out of place in this forum, got to say that the last post is an example of the historical intoxication so in vogue in Spain for too much time, even being against well documented information. Being that said, I'm not saying that the author was necessarily posting with such intention but with wrong information based in bad researching or deliberate misinformation. Again, not necessarily the fault of the author of the post (Txabier) but of the information he's been given or he has had access too. Sad situation when the bulk of information one can have depending on procedence is a censored, misinterpreted one (willingly or not). Gotta say it's not in my intention to be pejorative to Txabier but to, for the sake of truth and justice, put things where they must be and just telling the truth. I mean, Txabier, you will undoubtedly benefit from it. ;)
By parts:
-First, Tercio men were allocated in private homes. it's documented, and that's all. The Catalan law told that such billeting should be "a la catalana" (by Catalan norm, refer to the OP) and not " a la Lombarda" (by Lombard norm, full maintenance by private home owners and so).
-Catalan courts worked way different from Castilian ones. To be able to exact payment from Catalunya, the king first must had to negotiate laws and so. This way legislation procedures took priority. Only when such affairs were treated and worked out were funds demanded by the king conceded. In this the Catalan system showed itself very advanced in comparison with others and it made for a very demanding and belligerent political attittude by the Catalan authorities in defense of their rights (which by that time were the rights of the people ;) ). So it must be put clear that lack of Catalan founding was not by any means the acuse of lack of salaries and rations in the Spanish army.
-I don't know what went on by Naples and other places (Naples and Palermo rebelled too against Spanish rule) but that was the reality in Catalunya. Again, it's well documented. In fact, being the Catalan administration a strong civil one based on Constitution and well founded laws (I mean a strong juridic and political tradition, of course with limitations due to the times in regard to our concept of democracy and so on), it tended to document and record carefully everything that happened.
ALEA IACTA EST
User avatar
DOGGED
Legionary
 
Posts: 69
Joined: Fri Jul 17, 2009 7:50 am
Top

Re: The Reapers War

Postby DOGGED » Tue Jun 14, 2011 9:02 am

-Olivares did not count on Catalan rebellion to start a war with France. Such a conflict was already going on from years by then; in fact Catalunya hada had to rely on popular mobilisation and militias for self defense and had lost people by the thousands to inept Spanish commanding in Roussillon. Such ineptitude had the Tercios in Catalunya instead of campaigning in southern France, for example, to make for an occupation army to enforce Olivares "Union de Armas" policy.
- The "Union de Armas" (Union of Arms) was a Olivares policy that looked for extending taxation to every territory in the Peninsula to maintain the Spanish army. Now it has to be made clear that this policy was absolutely illegal in Catalunya. Catalunya was a realm by all means except by name. Ruled by the Counts of Barcelona, and then by the king of Spain because of his title of Count of Barcelona (and none else), Catalunya had a juridic, politic and legal system of her own and was not subject to Spanish law. It worked like a confederation of sorts. So the Catalan state had the king of Spain as its head of state, but it had its own institutions and judicial system which all worked by their own laws, absolutely independent of Spanish ones. It can really be said that Catalunya was ruled by a Count that was the equal to other states kings and so was recognised in the world by then. In fact Catalunya was named a Principality. Venice was a republic and had its Doge, for example. Catalan political tradition made its ruler a "primus inter pares". That "democratic" leaning made it impossible for a Catalan ruler to become king of Catalunya because it had been breaking the convention to not have an absolute ruler, to say so.
-Eveybody was eager to get American gold pillaged by Spanish conquistadors, be they British, Dutch or Spanish themselves. Catalunya was forbidden until mid XVIIIth century to do so, and its major markets were in Europe, including a growing and very important one both with France and with the British Islands and Netherlands (a country viewed by Catalans as an example of admiration both by its strongly independent nature and its enterprising efforts). Catalunya did not want to accept any taxation which was not legal by its own legal system, out of pure logic.
ALEA IACTA EST
User avatar
DOGGED
Legionary
 
Posts: 69
Joined: Fri Jul 17, 2009 7:50 am
Top

Re: The Reapers War

Postby DOGGED » Tue Jun 14, 2011 9:02 am

-Really, Olivares screwed it up driving Spain to a war it ultimately could not win, out of a typical lack of vision and willing ignorance of the reality of the kingdom. Spain should be then have limited itself to just defending, even emancipating some territories to at last have some kind of political and eceonomical influence over them and then concentrate on its American dominions. but I have to dissagree beacuse the Catalan front was one of particular interest to the Spanish crown. Such is so that it strategically renounced to Portugal to keep Catalunya. The war ended with Catalan defeat but the Catalan institutions and laws (its independent nature to say so) were all kept the same they were. North Catalonia was illegaly ceded by the Spanish monarch, who could not do so under the Catalan law which obliged him as Catalan head of state regarding Catalan soil as Roussillon was).
-It has to be said that these facts are widely ignored by Spanish people because they are just plain not told. Spanish people can't know by themselves unless doing ample research and going well beyond standard Spanish explanation for the conflict. So it's only logical that they make the same guessings Txabier made, not their fault. But it can be annoying for us Catalans because it seems we're always explaining the same things. It really is a forgotten (you could say even it's forbidden, for political reasons) front, moreso having into account it had people like De Melo, Condé and so campaigning...
Sorry for the large post. I don't want to look dismissing or pejorative to Txabier, just to be informative for the sake of truth and justice and that's why I took time and space to explain. Thanks for your attention. :)
EDIT: misspelled something...
ALEA IACTA EST
User avatar
DOGGED
Legionary
 
Posts: 69
Joined: Fri Jul 17, 2009 7:50 am
Top

Re: The Reapers War

Postby Txabier » Tue Jun 14, 2011 6:34 pm

Dogged, I agree with almost everything you say, but I still have to point out that there were many factors which were added to the equation by the Catalonian themselves.

I just lost a long post mentioning them all, but I'll try to be brief as I have some translation work that I need to do--daddy needs more minis! :lol:

Olivares did want a major, definitive confrontation with France. The battles so far were undecisive, no side winning the upper hand and continental hegemony was at satke for him.

The situation in Catalunya was as democratic as it was painted to be, and the county was immersed in severe economic and political crises, which by 1630 was all but untennable.

But there was a very curious situation: Catalunya was protected by the Imperial army, yet it repeatedly refused to contribute to the upkeep or the levying of troops to support it given "they had no interest in matter beyond their borders". It was a case of having your back covered while give the cover a cold shoulder. This, of course, infuriated Olivares and displeased the king.

The Castillian crown carried most of the load for the armies that protected the whole of the Empire, and as the resources got strained, Olivares and not few others insisted on a more equitative partition of the load among the provinces and territories accoring to the possiblities of each one--that is also a well-documented fact, Dogged.

Catalunya refused to even entertain the idea.

There was a deep-rooted hatred for the Viceroys for their politics against the bandoleros [mainly composed of peasants and shepherds trying to survive during the worst of the crisis] who preyed on the roads and commercial routes. Certain actions were interpreted as a "Castllian conspiracy" against the land by the nobles and it only helped in increasing the hatred for the "outsider king and his dogs."

Then, there was the "1639 slight", when basically the whole of Catalunya--and Madrid, too--refused to support Olivares scheme to make the territory the front of the wars against the French, in hopes of manipulating the Catalonians to fight and contribute to the war as it was de facto within their territories. Let us remember that the County refused to engage or support military actions outside their borders. Olivares thought he could circumvent that little fact with a clever twist, but failed miserably.

Then, an army under 10,000 men was stationed on Catalunya during winter, and it strained the already scarce resources of the people even more; yet, it must also be noted that the Laws of the County regarding the maintenance and boarding of troops were purposefully insufficient--and rightly so, I must add. When the soldiery went hungry, they resorted to confiscation [and more than a few cases of pillage] and other abuses which kept going well after the severe winter. This prompted the Gerundese to attack the Tercios they accomodated within their lands not their homesteads--a very important distinction-- and all hell broke loose.

As Olivares hoped it would. He knew that he wouldn't be able to make the armies scattered on other frontlines converge on Catalunya and quell the uprising--which he tought would only be a minor nuisance :roll:--, but it would give him plenty of time for the situation to go so tense enough for the Imperial court and quite desperate for the Catalonian, and thus to bring in the French for the "decisive bout for hegemony".

Yet, Olivares proved to be a less than stellar strategist. The minor nuisance turned into a veritable bloodbath and he reacted too late, opting for prudence at all costs--after almost of month of infamies by both sides. But it also proved too much for the Catalonian nobility, as the poor were imposible for them to control. Incapable of quelling the revolt and ruling an "independent state", they opted to align themselves to the French by proclaiming Louis XII as their Count and they went as far as to actually pay for an french army that was to be stationed on their territory!

Weren't the so abhorrent to do so all but less than a year before? Mark that as one big mistake for the nobility in Catalunya as they ended up doing excatly what they refused to do and which started the whole mess in the first place.

Yet, Olivares got what he wanted: an escalation of the war with France where the battles did have lasting effects for the Empire... it ended up its--and Olivares'--ambition of continentakl hegemony.

The war with Catalunya lasted 4 years more than the TYW, and reverted the county to being a Spanish-aligned territory.

On a final note: it was Louis XIV who invaded the transpyrenee Catalunya and who prohibited Catalan language and the use of the nobility's ancestral privileges and titles.

All this for the sake of truth and justice, too. ;)
Txabier
Raw Recruit
 
Posts: 16
Joined: Mon Apr 25, 2011 1:41 pm
Top

Re: The Reapers War

Postby Cubster » Tue Jun 14, 2011 7:27 pm

Is there an audio version of this thread?
"You're a big man, but you're in bad shape. With me, it's a full time job." – Lt. Bromhead to Prince Dabulamanzi before the Battle of Rorke's Drift.
User avatar
Cubster
Emperor
 
Posts: 6146
Joined: Mon May 24, 2010 9:36 am
Top

Next

Post a reply
16 posts • Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2

Return to Pike & Shotte General Discussion

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 2 guests

  • Board index
  • The team • Delete all board cookies • All times are UTC [ DST ]
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group