I think it is quite funny that what started off as a discussion about modern weapons has ended up as a discussion about bayonets!
Getting back to game mechanics, if we use the reversed firing and h-t-h stats suggested it would be virtually impossible for the British to successfully charge as per historical examples from the Zulu, Sudan or NW Frontier wars, and no player is ever going to voluntarily take on an opponent with twice as many h-t-h dice.
Taking the British company of say 100 men as a unit, are you saying that frontally, in close order with bayonets fixed, they were half as good at fighting as 100 Zulus in similar close order?
If you are then you need to do some more reading I'm afraid.
The argument that giving the British half dice promotes the British to charge, simply ignores history
Users browsing this forum: Exabot [Bot] and 1 guest